Am I overpaying for Bay?

[pedroia15]

I give Haren and Mclouth to get Bay. Am I overpaying?

I am fine on starting pitching, I have johan, beckett, wandy, bedard,and Carpenter.

[TheIceman]

I would say your overpaying for him. Haren alone should be enough to get Bay. You shouldn't need to include Mclouth

[ajk23az]

Unless your pitching is really deep. I wouldn't even give Haren for him.

[activechamp2006]

Unless your pitching is really deep. I wouldn't even give Haren for him.

IMO Bay is worth more then the guy who only pitches well in the first half. Not even close.
As for both Mclouth and Haren, I'd say you're giving to much. I'd expect to see a decent player a long with Bay to pull the trigger on this deal.

[TheNephilim]

I own Bay and wouldn't even think twice before denying a Bay for Haren deal. I don't think the Haren Mcclouth deal is not too far off. might have him toss in a mid range pitcher

[SDKSman]

in response to the above haren mclouth is fair no need to add any mid range anything what r u smokin

[Surfs up]

I traded Bay a couple of weeks ago. I included Mark Buhrele. But in return I received Markakis and Javy Vazquez. I think I did pretty good.

[BALCO All-Stars]

Bay for Haren is an equal trade (top OF for a top SP), so including McLouth might be too much