6 Player Deal. Yea or Nay??? WHIR!!!

[Pack83]

I'm trying to upgrade at SS and get some better depth at RP so here's the deal that's been offered.

I give Lopez, Gonzalez, and Aardsma for Tejada, Wells, and Cordero.

It's a H2H league where we keep 7. The Lopez/Aardsma part of the deal is a no-brainer I'm just not sure about giving up Gonzalez. Thoughts please? Thanks.

Offensive: R, HR, RBI, AVG, SB, E, K
Pitching: W, L, S, K, ERA, BS, BB

C: McCann, Baker
1B: Pena, Adrian Gonzalez
2B: Phillips, Hudson
3B: Longoria, Huff
SS: Tulowitzki, Felipe Lopez
OF: Braun, Torii Hunter, Hawpe, Span, Markakis, Granderson, Jose Guillen
SP: Billingsly, Gallardo, Kershaw, Lackey, Jered Weaver
RP: Paplebon, Lindstrom, Aardsma

[fierro33]

no i wouldnt do it.....gonzo is by far the best player in the deal....tejada and wellls are not really worth all that much


viewtopic.php?t=386297

[Roberto Clemente]

I would not do it either. A.Gonzalez is the major player in this deal...especially a Keeper League.

You could probably do better.

[the izzy]

thanks for the help on mine.

anyway, I agree w/ the other two, do not do this trade. Not a very good trade for you IMO

[Pack83]

What if it were Lopez/Huff/Aardsma for Tejada/Cordero? You guys like that any better or is it still a no.


C: McCann, Baker
1B: Pena, Adrian Gonzalez
2B: Phillips, Hudson
3B: Longoria, Huff
SS: Tulowitzki, Felipe Lopez
OF: Braun, Torii Hunter, Hawpe, Span, Markakis, Granderson, Jose Guillen
SP: Billingsly, Gallardo, Kershaw, Lackey, Jered Weaver
RP: Paplebon, Lindstrom, Aardsma

[theinflatinator91]

I really dont like the first deal. That would not be smart in a keeper because Gonzo is young and a very powerful hitter.

As for the other trade it doesnt really help you. You already have good closers so no need for Cordero. Also Felipe Lopez + Tulo tandem will be more beneficial to you than Tejada.

help with mine? - viewtopic.php?f=94&t=386430

[as834625]

Adrian Gonzalez is the best player no one talks about... he is always a steal on draft day because of his team and their home park .. if you are a decent salesman, you could probably go after a guy like rollins + a mid level closer if you propose gonzalez + aardsma

i would think so. .

[SDKSman]

DONT DO IT gonzo is gonna have a career yr if u trade him treat it like your tradin a rd1 or rd2 guy