CC Trade WHIR

[Philly_05]

I trade -
Saunders
Soriano
Moustakas

I get -
Sabathia

Roster -

C- Ramon Hernandez
1B- Miguel Cabrera
2B- Brandon Phillips
SS- Hanley Ramirez
3B- Alex Rodriguez
OF- Grady Sizemore
OF- Alfonso Soriano
OF- Matt Holliday
OF- Jermaine Dye
UT- Orlando Hudson

Bench- Milton Bradley, Willy Taveras, Juan Pierre

Farm- Matt LaPorta, Daniel Murphy, Alberto Callaspo, Jason Heyward, Brett Wallace, Mike Moustakas, Yonder Alonso, Carlos Santana, Dayan Viciedo, Wilmer Flores

DL- Travis Hafner, Jorge Posada

P- Johan Santana
P- John Lackey
P- Chris Carpenter
P- Joe Saunders
P- Mike Pelfrey
P- Ricky Nolasco
RP- Francisco Rodriguez
RP- Francisco Cordero
RP- George Sherrill
RP- Ramon Ramirez
RP- Huston Street
RP- Brian Bruney

Farm- Rick Porcello, Jhoulys Chacin, Kyle Drabek, JA Happ, Nick Barnese

DL- Shawn Kelley, Jason Schmidt

12 Team Fantasy Point Large Keepers i'm in 9th place out of 12. This trade is on the trade box and the other owner likes it but it holding on it until tomorrow is this a good deal for my team? I think I could really use CC and can take the hit in the OF and on my prospects. Or should I ask for a little more with CC?

[bazzy_51]

i say you should ask for a little more... i mean yes you have 3 OF on your bench but Bradley IMO isn't gonna come even close to what he did last year (stupid cubs) and Pierre only has what bout 40 more games? so your looking at starting Taveras unless Bradley pulls his head out of, yeah... look to get something even if small back with CC... your prospects are fine with out Mous...

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=386316

[reblaze369]

I agree CC plus an a useful OF would work.

[Philly_05]

His OF are..

Adam Jones
Vernon Wells
Coco Crisp
Franklin Gutierrez
Manny Ramirez
Andrew Lambo
Conor Jackson

Should I ask for Wells I know he was willing to move him before but we have not talked about him in this offer.

[guyincognito]

I agree that you should get more in return then just CC. Wells could work. If you could swing Jones, I would, but I'm sure he'd want more. Manny is interesting as well if he's down on him and wants to move him. But Wells would be a good piece to close up the deal.

Help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386323

[Howie]

I agree that you should get more in return then just CC. Wells could work. If you could swing Jones, I would, but I'm sure he'd want more. Manny is interesting as well if he's down on him and wants to move him. But Wells would be a good piece to close up the deal.

This is good advice. Losing Soriano by himself is too much for C.C. If you could get him to "throw in" Wells, Jones, or even ManRam, things would tilt in your favor. Thanks for the help on mine.

[Philly_05]

Guy just a heads up on the scoring the last 4 years for Soriano and CC.

Soriano

364 fp 3.4 average fp/g
425 fp 3.1 average fp/g
551 fp 3.5 average fp/g
489 fp 3.1 average fp/g

Sabathia

860 fp 24.6 fp/g
746 fp 21.9 fp/g
557 fp 19.9 fp/g
505 fp 16.3 fp/g

[Regalus]

I dont have to much experience with such a deep keeper league, so keep that in mind when you read this.

If it were me, I would try and add another outfielder into this trade if possible. Your team looks good on paper, but I know seizmore's gotta be killing you now. What would it take to get Adam Jones away from him? I would probably pass on the deal as is. If he cant cough up something else, then wait. Im suprised your rank is so low, I think it will bounce back.

[Philly_05]

Pulled the offer sent a message to him waiting to see what OF'ers are available. Yeah my team started off slow without Carp/Lackey and A Rod for awhile didn't help. Carmona/Nolasco/Sizemore/Holliday all starting slow to horrible didn't help. I finally cut bait on Carmona today. Some rankings are fake because they have a good number of starts more than I do. I shouldn't have any problem getting into the top 3 or 4 teams if I stay healthy.

[billycent]

Don't even do this trade. Soriano is a STUD! C.C. isn't consistent enough and I think ur pitching is pretty good anyway. If anything, trade away Holliday or something and take a smaller name pitcher. If nothing else, ur not getting fair value in exchange. Thanks for the help on mine.