Hill and Roberts

[robilmc]

This one is killing me. I drafted B Roberts 3rd or 4th and scooped up Hill after another owner dropped him 3 weeks ago. With Weeks going down I've got 5 or 6 other owners begging me to move either Hill or Roberts. Sell high on Hill or ask the moon and stars for Roberts? I'm sorely tempted to roll the dice on Hill and trade Roberts. All advice welcome.

[johnjacob04]

This one is killing me. I drafted B Roberts 3rd or 4th and scooped up Hill after another owner dropped him 3 weeks ago. With Weeks going down I've got 5 or 6 other owners begging me to move either Hill or Roberts. Sell high on Hill or ask the moon and stars for Roberts? I'm sorely tempted to roll the dice on Hill and trade Roberts. All advice welcome.

I would sell high on Hill and stick with Roberts. Hes pretty steady.

[the izzy]

I'm in the same situation - having both B. Roberts and Hill. I'm in a keeper league too, so at the end of the year I can keep Roberts for a 4th rd pick or A. Hill for a 23rd rd pick. This gives Hill extra value as keeping him is so cheap.

Anyway, if you need SB + R then keep B. Roberts
If you need HR + RBI keep A. Hill (although, most people project Hill to only finish w/ 22 or so HR, giving him 10 more HR over the next 4 months.)

[Zain1two3]

Forget about pre season predictions because Hill has arrived this season. He hits second, in front of someone with the best OBP in baseball with Rios Wells and Lind after him. Keep Hill, sell Roberts for whatever help you require. Roberts plays for the Orioles who will finish in last place.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390143