need help with this blockbuster WHIR!

[fierro33]

been offered:

morneau
reyes
lackey

for my:

miggy
rollins
ichiro


my offense is already set, so the question is do i need the extra sp?


10 team 5x5 H2H


C Mauer
1b Miguel Cabrera
2b Brian Roberts
3b Alex Rodriguez
ss Michael Young
of Manny ramirez
of Carl Crawford
of Nate Mclouth
util Ichiro Suzuki

bench:
magglio ordonez
adam jones

DL
Stephen Drew



SP

CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Kevin Slowey
Josh Johnson
wainwright
scherzer


lidge
fuentes
capps
zeigler

[bosoxrock34]

The trade is a 50 50 trade but the key piece is you getting Reyes... Do you need Reyes? You have Crawford.. You have OK pitching I wouldnt do it just to upgrade Pitching... I hope ur not starting Manny....

some help
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386299

[fierro33]

anyone else

[fierro33]

this is a tough one

[fierro33]

[murphysxm]

I personally wouldn't do it. You are selling low on both Rollins and Miggy who are starting to wake up a little. Plus there is no gurantee with Lackey

Help me if you can
viewtopic.php?t=386391

[murphysxm]

my bad. Thought it was Mags, not Miggy

[fierro33]

im confused....if u thought it was mags then it would be a no-brainer wouldnt it?

[Coachsays]

I wouldn't do it. I like your team as is and I don't like Lackey all that much...wait and see if he's really healthy. Reyes may be hurt too.

[Hit Factory]

Thanks for the help with mine! I would not make this trade, Reyes has a nagging injury and I don't like Lackey, plus your pitching staff is ok without him.