Sabathia Trade WHIR

[milkshake]

trade- K Rod, Soriano and Saunders

get- Marmol, Sabathia, Gutierrez

My remaining OF on my team would be Sizemore, Holliday, Pierre, Dye, Taveras, Bradley and Gutierrez we start 4 OF each day.

My RP would be Carlos Marmol, Francisco Cordero, Ramon Ramirez, George Sherrill, Huston Street, Brian Bruney and Shawn Kelley we count holds and saves 53/240 RP games used so far.

MY SP would be Sabathia, Santana, Lackey, Carpenter, Carmona, Nolasco, Pelfrey, Porcello, Happ.

I could careless about getting Gutierrez should I take the offer since Marmol is a really good RP and Soriano and Saunders is a very great deal to get Sabathia? Or should I counter and ask for Wells or Adam Jones instead of Gutierrez? Fantasy points 12 team keeper league will very large keepers.

Will WHIR for anyone.

[Coachsays]

Thanks for the help with mine.

I would ask for Jones or Wells. Might as well start high and then you can work your way down to Guitierez. I think it's a solid deal for you. I don't like Saunders at all.

[wyld stallions]

I think you are paying too much. CC is good, but will not match his number from last year. And playing in NY is going to hurt him a bit.

help me please: viewtopic.php?t=386063

[UGADawgGuy]

I would definitely ask for more in return. But even then, I wouldn't count on Sabathia being the pitcher he was in Cleveland. He's still a big-time talent in a big uniform, but I wouldn't expect greatness from him as a Yankee.

I'd consider not making this trade at all, honestly.

Thanks for the help with mine! viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386062

-- UGADawgGuy

[TrippySG]

I would definitely ask for more in return.

I'd consider not making this trade at all, honestly.

-- UGADawgGuy

Ditto. I love Sabathia, but I dont think Soriano and KRod are worth him honestly. Marmol is doing good now, but closers have a way of losing their usefullness as a season develops, and there is competition in Chicago. And if you arent getting someone useful for the third guy, why even make a 3 person trade. If you can get Adam Jones this deal will be in your favor, if not I dont think youre getting what youre giving

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=386052

[milkshake]

Update I just looked over the rosters and he can't even trade Marmol because the guy who owned the team last year franchised him. So I sent a counter of..

Moustakas
Saunders
Soriano

for

Sabathia

What do you guys think of that? I got plenty of kids so Mous doesn't really matter to me and it might entice him into doing the trade?

[jmcampbe11]

Do you really need CC? Your pitching staff seemed stacked as is. Soriano for CC (basically what you're countering with) seems pretty even, but I personally don't think you need him.

[METS 24]

Deleted

[pappymojo]

I would rather have Soriano over Sabathia.

viewtopic.php?t=386083

[zedtech78]

Thanks for the help w/ mine. I 100% ditto this...

Rodriguez > Marmol
Soriano > Gutierrez
Saunders < Sabathia