Granderson or B.J. Upton

[perlick29]

Chad Billingsley is being highly sought after. I turned down a trade that would have me send Billingsley away for Ellsbury.

I have three other possibilities now on the table:

Would you trade Billingsley for BJ Upton or Curtis Granderson, or how about Carlos Lee? Here's my roster again:

C B. Molina (SF - C)
1B A. Dunn (WAS – 1B, OF)
2B A. Hill (TOR – 2B)
3B M.Cabrera (DET - 1B, 3B)
SS J. Reyes (NYM - SS)
OF K. Morales (LAA – 1B,OF)
OF H. Pence (HOU - OF)
OF V. Wells (TOR - OF)
Util H. Matsui (NYY – OF)
BN E. Dukes (WAS - OF)
BN G. Sheffield (NYM - OF)


SP Z. Greinke (KC - SP)
SP C. Billingsley (LAD – SP)
RP M. Gonzalez (ATL - RP)
RP B. Fuentes (LAA - RP)
P C.J. Wilson (TEX - RP)
P U. Jimenez (COL - SP)
P C. Marmol (CHC - RP)
BN E. Jackson (DET – SP)
BN J. Johnson (BAL – RP)
BN D. Bush (MIL – SP)
BN M. Garza (TB - SP)

Thanks for your help.

[jmcampbe11]

With Reyes already on your team Billingsley for Lee would be your best move. I'd still try to shop Garza instead.

[cstorms]

If I was you I would hang onto Billingsley.

[daullaz]

If you're set on trading Bills, I would only do it for Carlos Lee on that list.

[SDKSman]

Id keep bills but like the guy above said if u do for lee

[theinflatinator91]

I'm a big fan of offense. Getting someone who impacts your team everyday other than once or twice per week will have a greater impact. That being said I love Bills. He had done great so far and has put up great numbers the last few years.

If this was me I would package Bills/Moralas or Matsui for Lee and a pitcher of his. That would be a great deal for you exp if he is sold on Bills doing what he has been in every start.