BIG Trade WHIR

[claudish21]

Hi guys,

I was offered this trade and was wanted to get some thourghts.

Webb, Youkllis, Chipper Qualls & S Drew for Wright, Choo, Phillips & Bell

I think its a great trade in that i get a top of the line SP and a future SS to replace Furcal. The loss is the saves between Bell and Qualls is nil.

Any help would be great

10 team roto league (13 keepers 3 minor leaguers)

5*5

BA R HR RBI SB

C McCann, Brian C ATL
1B Gonzalez, Adrian 1B
2B Utley, Chase 2B PHI
3b Wright, David 3B NYM
SS Furcal, Rafael SS LA
MI Phillips, Brandon 2B CIN
CI Loney, James 1B LA
OF Wells, Vernon CF TOR
OF Victorino, Shane CF PHI
OF Cruz, Nelson R. RF TEX
OF Fowler, Dexter CF COL
Of Werth, Jayson RF PHI
UT Choo, Shin-Soo RF CLE

BN Burrell, Pat LF TB


W S K ERA WHIP

P Beckett, Josh SP
P Haren, Dan SP ARI
P Lester, Jon SP BOS
P Arredondo, Jose RP ANA
P Bell, Heath RP SD
P Downs, Scott RP TOR
P Madsen, Ryan RP Phil
P Lindstrom, Matt RP FLA
P Morrow, Brandon SP SEA

BN Jurrjens, Jair SP ATL
BN Masterson, Justin SP BOS

Minors
Beckham, Tim SS TB
Heyward, Jason OF ATL
Perez, Chris RP STL

[bloul11]

I think i would go ahead and take that. like you said drew is an upcoming SS and Webb is solid already. Losing all the tools of wright sucks but you gotta give a little get a little.

please help
viewtopic.php?t=385668

[WyldStallyn]

not a good idea to give up the best player in the deal, especially when he's a lot better than the other players. unless you think his slow start is what to expect out of wright in the future, i wouldnt do this