Thoughts on This Deal in a Keeper League - THX

[Modock]

12 team roto:

a gets: Joe Mauer, Derek Jeter & Kevin Gregg

b gets: Francisco Rodriguez & Jimmy Rollins (can't be kept)


thx

[bcbhockey68]

I Like B Rollins will turn it around....I hope. Thanks for the help on mine.

[Xezus]

long term it is just jeter, mauer and gregg for k-rod... Mauer is a gem and i like his side of the trade, not being able to keep rollins turns the tide in favor of A, short term i would say team b, but i think you get a much side going for team A =)

[mac-unit]

A if you can take the saves loss.
Mauer for K-Rod is in favor of the side getting Mauer. In a 12 team league saves can be found elsewhere. Solid production at the catcher position is harder to come by.

Rollins is over rated and I wouldn't be surprised if Jeter puts up better numbers by years end, throw in Gregg who's still a closer and it's worth it imo.

[Fan Interference]

I would take A, but i have no idea who my catcher is right then. but i would take this trade and try to trade off jeter to the leagues die hard yankees fan.

[soty]

I would take A. Mauer is a beast at catcher and like mac said you can get your saves elsewhere.

[Carnac]

I also like the a side of the deal.