Was this a bad move??

[prophet_x]

I recently made a trade in my 14-team yahoo h2h league. And I'm thinking I made a very bad trade (Keep in mind I'm a Jays fan, so it most likely altered my state of mind lol). So the trade was his BJ Ryan/Scott Downs/Kevin Slowey for my Joe Nathan/Chad Qualls. I figured that since the Jays are on a roll and with both closers I have a good chance of racking up saves and plus I get a decent starter.

my squad:

Mike Napoli
Lyle Overbay
Brian Roberts
Emilio Bonifacio
J.J. Hardy
Vernon Wells
Adam Lind
Ichiro Suzuki
Carlos Quentin
Álex Ríos
Nick Swisher
Garrett Atkins
Carlos Delgado
Ryan Ludwick

Roy Halladay
Jair Jurrjens
Chad Qualls
Joe Nathan
Scott Richmond
CC Sabathia
LaTroy Hawkins
Huston Street

his squad:

A.J. Pierzynski
Justin Morneau
José López
Pedro Feliz
Hanley Ramírez
Ryan Braun
Andre Ethier
Justin Upton
Denard Span
Willy Taveras
Chris Young
Aramis Ramírez

Javier Vázquez
Jered Weaver
Scott Downs
George Sherrill
Edwin Jackson
Cliff Lee
Ervin Santana
Randy Wolf
Kevin Slowey
B.J. Ryan