My Sizemore/Qualls 4 His Utley/Francisco?

[jmcampbe11]

I'm taking on some risk trading for Francisco while he's on the DL, but is it worth it to land Utley? Francisco, is eligible to come off the DL next Friday.

I GIVE - Sizemore/Qualls
I GET - Utley/F.Francisco (Texas' closer)

[MadDog36]

i like the other trade better b/c it really gives your lnieup balance. this one doesn't solve all ur needs.

[jmcampbe11]

i like the other trade better b/c it really gives your lnieup balance. this one doesn't solve all ur needs.

I'm actually looking at making both of these. Does that change your opinion?

TRADE 1 - Sizemore/Qualls for Utley/F.Francisco
AND
TRADE 2 - Hamilton/A.Gonzalez/Ad.Jones/Reynolds/Greinke 4 M.Cabrera/Markakis/Zimmerman/Choo/Halladay

OLD TEAM--------------------NEW TEAM
C-Martin-----------------------SAME
1B-A.Gonzalez-----------------M.Cabrera
2b-Phillips----------------------SAME
SS-Alx.Ramirez----------------SAME
3B-Longoria--------------------SAME
CI-Reynolds--------------------Zimmerman
MI-J.Lopez---------------------Utley
OF-Sizemore-------------------Markakis
OF-Hamilton-------------------Choo
OF-Dye--------------------------SAME
OF-V.Wells---------------------SAME
OF-Crisp------------------------SAME
UT-Ad.Jones-------------------J.Lopez or best avaliable FA
SP-Greinke---------------------Halladay
SP-Gallardo---------------------SAME
SP-Lilly--------------------------SAME
SP-Carpenter-------------------SAME
SP-Jimenez---------------------SAME
RP-Broxton---------------------SAME
RP-Qualls-----------------------F.Francisco
RP-Percival---------------------SAME
RP-Morrow----------------------SAME
RP-Ray--------------------------SAME
DL-Smoltz-----------------------SAME