Trade Help

[lbj812]

I give: Matt Holliday, Chris Davis, Brett Cecil, Troy Percival
I get: Johnny Damon, Mark Reynolds, Chris Ianetta, Ted Lilly, and Brian Fuentes
Should I give up Randy Johnson instead of Cecil in this trade or not?
Should I accept this trade?

[Carnac]

Is this a keeper league? Rosters?

[lbj812]

no keeper but i have kurt suzuki at catcher, we'd be trading OF my closers are morrow percival nathan and my SP solid.
1B- Votto
2B-Alexei
3B-Davis
SS-Rollins
1/3-Davis
2/ss-Furcal
OF- Bay, Kemp, Ibanez, Holliday, Abreu
Util- Thome
SP- Harang, Baker, Danks, Nolasco, Cecil , Randy, Myers, Buehrle, Ubaldo, Kershaw
RP- Nathan, Percival, Morrow

[dicehound]

I like this deal quite a bit for you. At first I didn't but then I looked closer. Holliday and Damon are virtually even, IMO. I'm sad to say it but I think it's true, and then you've got Reynolds and Davis, who are also pretty much even; so then you've got Iannetta, Lilly and Fuentes for Cecil and Percy. That's a beautiful trade for you. And if you can spin Johnson instead of Cecil I'd say do it.