Medlen or Coghlan

[Slow Pitch]

I think Coghlan is more valueable but with my roster maybe Medlen is right for me:

I have 1 free roster spot.

Starters:

Soto
Molina
Pujols
Matsui
Hanley
C.Davis
MCab
Bartlett
Choo
A. Jones
K. Morles
Pierre
Lind
Berkman

Bench: Manny, Andrus, Snider, G. Beckham

SP Lincecum
SP Halladay
SP Yoga
SP Guthrie
SP Zito
RP Percy
RP Downs
RP Cruz
RP Bell

Bench: Hanson, Tillman

[Slow Pitch]

Anyone?