Sell High on A.Jones to Land Utley? WHIR

[jmcampbe11]

10 team roto league. Thoughts on this trade? Good sell high on Adm. Jones? For context, my worst category is batting average.

I GIVE-----------------I GET
Sizemore-------------Utley
Qualls-----------------Lind (If he insists on Broxton is it still worth making?)
Ad.Jones-------------Rios

C-Martin
1b-A.Gonzalez 3b-Longoria
2b-Phillips ss-Alx.Ramirez
MI-J.Lopez CI-Reynolds
OF-Sizemore, Hamilton
OF-Ad.Jones, V.Vells, Dye
Util-Crisp
SP-Greinke, Gallardo, Lilly, R.Johnson, Nolasco, Carpenter, Smoltz
RP-Broxton, Qualls, Morrow, Percival, Ray

[jmcampbe11]

Anyone?

[Wood+Prior=DL]

Hmmm...tough call on this one. I do like Utley as the best player in this deal; however, Sizemore will eventually pick it up. You already have Phillips at 2B; I'm assuming you would move Crisp out of the Util spot, if you obtained Utley. I would not do this deal if they ask for Broxton...as for the current deal, I think I'm still swaying with you keeping your current players.

[jmcampbe11]

Hmmm...tough call on this one. I do like Utley as the best player in this deal; however, Sizemore will eventually pick it up. You already have Phillips at 2B; I'm assuming you would move Crisp out of the Util spot, if you obtained Utley. I would not do this deal if they ask for Broxton...as for the current deal, I think I'm still swaying with you keeping your current players.

Utley would replace Jose Lopez at my middle infield slot. Still feel the same?

[Wood+Prior=DL]

Hmmm...tough call on this one. I do like Utley as the best player in this deal; however, Sizemore will eventually pick it up. You already have Phillips at 2B; I'm assuming you would move Crisp out of the Util spot, if you obtained Utley. I would not do this deal if they ask for Broxton...as for the current deal, I think I'm still swaying with you keeping your current players.

Utley would replace Jose Lopez at my middle infield slot. Still feel the same?

Still a tough deal to me; Rios is really the factor I'm looking at here, as I've never really been a huge fan of his...

[jmcampbe11]

Geesh.This board is dead. Anyone else?

[jmcampbe11]

anyone?

[pappymojo]

It's a balanced trade but I would probably do it if I were you. I would not do this if he insisted on Broxton. With Qualls, okay.

[D.Piston]

It's pretty fair. But no way if he wants Broxton. I'd rather have Adam Jones and Sizemore though. As long as Jones isn't too hurt, I feel like he will be one of those players who help teams win championships. Thanks for helping me.

[bcbhockey68]

I would personally rather have Adam Jones and Sizemore to be honest. Thanks for the help on mine.