McClouth/Bedard for Soriano/Baker - WHIR

[smackarito]

Please advise me guys, it is a standard roto league, 5 X 5, money, yada yada yada... my lineup is good to go, I am definitely in need of another very good SP, and I was offered this trade - Erik Bedard and Nate McClouth for Alfonso Soriano and Scott Baker... now, I just picked up Baker off the FA list, his start yesterday he gave up 4 runs... in any case, is that a good trade for me to make? Or should I just stick with these guys and work on another package trade? Sori has been fine, I wasn't looking to deal him, it's an offer that was made to me, and Bedard is a pretty good pitcher... please help...

[RRGL1]

No way on that offer. I'd stick with Soriano/Baker.

Bedard still makes me nervous so I don't see him as a significant upgrade. IMO, Baker is getting back on track. And of course, Soriano>>McClouth