Grady/Beltran/Morneau or Kinsler/Crawford/Howard?? WHIR WHIR

[Turbostasis25]

12 team 14 cat h2h with extras being walks, holds K/9 and complete games... trying to pull a blockbuster

Roster:

C Russell Martin
1b Ryan Howard
2b Kinsler
SS Marco Scutaro
3c Peralta
OF Quentin
OF Damon
OF Crawford
Util Vicotrino
BN Magglio
BN Tavearas
BN J Upton
BN Loney
DL Doumit

Liriano
F. Hernandez
Scherzer
Greinke
Buehrle
Wandyrod

Gregg
Fuentes
Brian Wilson

DL Dice k


Need help with his this HUUUGE blockbuster offer

My

Howard Kinsler Quentin Crawford Damon Ordonez F. Hernandez

His

Sizemore Beltran Morneau Figgins Billingsly Bedard

Should I do it? seems like it could go either way, it helps that I'm benching 3/4 OFers every day and I'm losing some here, and I could definitely use the pitching upgrade. WHIR

[Fantasy GM]

That's a lot of players! I think this trade involves TOO MANY big players to pull off. As for looking into the trade itself, I'm not sure I like this for you. Howard isn't as consistent as Morneau, but he tend to dominate in the second half. Kinsler and Utley are by far the two best 2B, and you're not getting a replacement. I like Billingsley a lot and Bedard has done well for the most part so far too, so the trade would improve your pitching (even though Felix is pretty good himself). Sizemore and Beltran obviously help the OF, your UTL would need to be somebody like Loney.

Again, it helps in some areas and hurts in others. IMO, there are too many big players here to make such a trade. I probably keep your side because I don't know how you plan to replace Kinsler if you trade him. Figgins is ok at 3B and I'm unsure if Scutaro is going to continue hitting this well all year.

Which SP do you like most? viewtopic.php?t=385190

[dagactor]

I would stick with what you got. You have the better players.

[jmcampbe11]

You're giving up too much. Stick with the players you have.

Can you help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=385230