Berkman/Lind for Howard/Hart...Counter....100% WHIR

[philaphan]

Alright, I posted a trade offer I receive the other day of My: Berkman/Ibanez for His: Howard/Hart.

I than counter with MY:Berkman/Ibanez for His: Howard/Holliday.

He rejected that trade but he counter with My:Berkman/Phillips/E. Santana for
His: Howard/Uggla/Hart.

I plan on countering with MY: Berkman/Lind for His Howard/Hart.

Is this a fair counter by me? I am trying to be reseaonable with the counter. I will post both are roster below. 100% WHIR just leave a link!

MY Roster
10 Team Head2Head 5X5
C:Suzuki
1b:Berkman
2b:Phillips
3b:Atkins
SS:Rollins
OF:Braun, Crawford, Ibanez
Util:Lind
BN:Ordonez, Reynolds
DL: Posada
SP:Peavy, Grienke
RP: Papelbon, Downs
SP/RP: Santan, Danks, C. Young
BN: E. Jackson, Scherzer

OTHER MANAGERS ROSTER:
C: Soto
1B: Howard
2B: Uggla
3B: ARod
SS: Hardy
OF: Hamilton, Holiday, Cruz
Util: Hunter
BN: Hart, Inge, Kendrick
SP: Harden, Bedard
RP: Hoffman, Bell
SP/RP: Pettitte, Dempster, Lindstrom
BN: Valverde, Millwood
DL: Dice-K

[AshesOfEmpires]

I think it's reasonable and it might get the job done. I'd take it.

[smoovethug]

Shouldn't get the job done at all. Both of his players are better than yours.

[woowoo crew]

With the way Lind has been playing, I think it's fair on paper. Based on past experience, maybe not so much, b/c we know what Hart can do. Still, I think it's a fair offer, and I'd do it.

Help me Please: viewtopic.php?t=385274

[philaphan]

If my counter isn't enough should I try to go back to Berkman/Ibanez for Howard/Hart????

I want Howard but Berkman for Howard won't work. What would be a decent counter? Should I may be target Inge and play him at 3B? I am hurting at 3B big time right now.

[woowoo crew]

why not offer berkman and lind or ibanez to the guy who has zimmerman at 3B and ask for a 1B in the deal too? i'm not sure if he has a guy you're interested in, but i agree with you about your need at 3B. inge is a nice option too, as is sandoval in my opinion. they wouldn't require as much in return in a trade as zimmerman.

thanks for looking at mine. i posted a comment to you there: viewtopic.php?t=385274

[philaphan]

The guy who has Zimm also has Pujols...Berkman isn't getting that deal done. The guy who has Sandoval really tough to deal with. He is the kind of manager that always wants and never gives!