lidge for phillips? WHIR

[fierro33]

been offered phillips for my lidge

do it even tho i already have weeks and derosa?

phillips has more value here, but with morrow struggling and soria hurt can i afford to do this? pap,nathan,and street would be my other closers


10 team 5x5 h2h

C Ianetta
1b Pena
2b Weeks
3b Wright
ss Reyes
OF Wells
OF Ibanez
OF Ellsbury
Util Alex Rodriguez
Bobby Abreu
pablo sandoval
weiters
Derosa




Lincecum
Sabathia
Peavy
Burnett
Gallardo
Baker
Slowey
Wandy


Papelbon
Nathan
Lidge
street

Morrow DL
Soria DL

[Fantasy GM]

Is there another team in your league that is weak at 2B. If so, you could acquire Phillips and then try to trade Weeks. You're solid in saves as it is with Papelbon/Nathan and Soria coming back (hopefully) soon. Phillips is hot right now and there's a chance Lidge is hurt (his ERA is still very high and there are some whispers in Philly something might be up).

I'd say pull the deal and begin looking for another team that could use Weeks. And how'd you draft such a stacked team - please tell me this is a keeper?

Which SP do you like: viewtopic.php?t=385190

[coma]

Is there another team in your league that is weak at 2B. If so, you could acquire Phillips and then try to trade Weeks. You're solid in saves as it is with Papelbon/Nathan and Soria coming back (hopefully) soon. Phillips is hot right now and there's a chance Lidge is hurt (his ERA is still very high and there are some whispers in Philly something might be up).

I'd say pull the deal and begin looking for another team that could use Weeks. And how'd you draft such a stacked team - please tell me this is a keeper?

Which SP do you like: viewtopic.php?t=385190

+1. I don't think you can pass up the value here. Phillips has been playing great.. You have Paps and Nathan so you shouldn't be hurting too much. See if you can trade Weeks..

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=385142

[fan of the cubs]

I would hold onto Lidge

[ltrocq]

do this deal as quickly as possible. there isn't anyone better in FA than morrow? he has been pitching terrible and may lose his job.

[philaphan]

Yes do this trade! Your have Pas & Nathan...you can afford to lose lidge. Phillips is an upgrade at 2B. Do the deal!

Please help me!
viewtopic.php?t=385192