I'm going to jump on the "Matt will turn it around" bandwagon.
Do you think (whether or not he stays in Oakland) Holliday > BJ?
BJ Upton -U
Bench-Granderson, A-Rod, C. Hart
Pitchers-Lincecum, Lee, Billingsley, Lowe, E. Santana, Meche, Greinke, Bedard, J. Johnson, K-Rod