Big Trade: Wright for Braun/Wieters?

[Bosy Billups]

Post trade, which Lineup would you choose for a keeper league (in it to win it this year, though).

Lineup A
C – Wieters
1B – Pujols
2B – Cano
3B – Stewart / Gamel
SS – Hanley
CI – Butler / LaPorta
OF – Markakis
OF - Braun
OF – J. Upton
OF – Wells
DH – Hart
DH – Bourn
B – Dukes
B – LaPorta
B - Gamel

Lineup B
C – Soto
1B – Pujols
2B – Cano
3B – Wright
SS – Hanley
CI – I. Stewart / Butler / LaPorta
OF – Markakis
OF – J. Upton
OF – Wells
OF – Hart
DH - Dukes
DH – Bourn
B – Butler
B – LaPorta
B - Gamel

[Coachsays]

How many keepers?

[cnasty]

who cares u have either hanley wright and pujols or put braun in there either way how could u lose the guys in ur league are retards

[Bosy Billups]

We keep 15 players, actually.

btw: It took years to get this roster together... and it's also a pretty shallow league.

[hambone1818]

Considering the rest of your team I'd take Wieters/Braun over Wright. The potential for Wieters is sky high, the same as J. Upton...having the two of them, plus Pujols, Braun and Hanley, on one keeper roster is pretty ridiculous. My guess is your team is winning 4-5 offensive cats every week, the downgrade from Wright to Braun--and there really isn't much of any--is well, well worth it considering you'll still win the 4-5 cats and have a guy who could be the best catcher in baseball as early as next year.

any help here?
viewtopic.php?t=385179

[Bosy Billups]

Thanks. That was my thinking too. Although, I have to state I'd be giving up Soto.