Lincecum Trade - Help! - WHIR

[Wile E Coyote]

I've been offered this trade:

HIS Chris Davis, MArk DeRosa and Lincecum for
MY Garrett Atkins, Brandon Phillips and Billingsley

I think Davis is a big upgrade over ATkins (especially once atkins is traded away from Coors Field) and Lincecum will do better than Billingsley in everthing except Wins (especially K's, K/BB and K/9)

Should I take this trade?

[woowoo crew]

oh yeah, you take this deal. chris davis is getting hot, while atkins could lose his job. great deal for you.

help me please: viewtopic.php?t=385069

[jmcampbe11]

I don't like the trade for you. I'm not convinced Davis is an upgrade over Atkins. I think Atkins will snap out of his funk soon.

Please vote - viewtopic.php?t=385092

[Poremski1628]

Not sold on this one. Phillips is getting hot, Atkins could pick it up at any time, and Lincecum is nice upgrade but Billingsley is never a bad option.

viewtopic.php?t=385102

[Wile E Coyote]

what if i tried to add HIS Danks for MY Maholm?
Would that make the deal worthwhile?
I am conscious of the K/BB and K/9 categories in this league

Is the biggest problem in this losing Phillips for DeRosa?

[Coachsays]

I think losing Phillips over Derosa is a fairly big deal...however, you are getting the best player in the deal with Lincecum...by far. I always like to be on that end of the trade.

Thoughts on mine?
[http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=385170url][/url]

[plainyogurt]

Thanks for opinion.

Don't give up on atkins yet. And it's nor 100% he will get traded. Lincecum would be nice pickup but billingsly might end year with more wins... Don't know how Davis will do for a full year...

I would stick with what you got. Maholm I believe had one bad outing, but danks is solid