Manny for Webb?

[Sunsr4u2njoy]

Both Manny and Webb are out until July with Webb maybe coming back a week or two earlier.
I give: Webb and Mark Teahen
I get: Manny Ramirez

What do you all think? I LOVE Webb but AZ hasn't done much this year and he is coming back from injury whereas Manny is not injured and we know when he is coming back. I need help with HR and RBI and Manny would do that for me. Plus, we have guys like Ubaldo, Carpenter, Meche, Saunders and Jurrjens on the Waiver.

Is the trade worth it?

SP Dan Haren
SP Wandy Rodríguez
SP Francisco Liriano
RP Joe Nathan
RP Scott Downs
P Heath Bell
P Chris Young
BN Clayton Kershaw
BN Brandon Webb
BN John Lackey
DL Joakim Soria

[Sunsr4u2njoy]

This is a big trade, somebody must have some sort of input.

BUMP

[Sportsmonkey]

I would do it.

Manny was drafted higher for a reason, Teahen is a nice filler while he's hot, but you can find a replacement on the WW.

The clincher for me is you know Manny will rake when he gets back, and has a fixed return date. With Webb you don't know if he's going to have setbacks or if he'll be 100% when he gets back.

This from a guy who just traded for Webb, so I'm trying to be optimistic.

Help me? viewtopic.php?t=385002

[Howie]

I'd do it. You have some nice anchor SPs on your staff, especially with Lackey coming back. Teahen is obviously a throw in, so I'd rather have Manny than Webb straight up.