should I make this deal (updated offer)

[surlytruckdrivr]

5x5 rotisserie, LTK, no contracts or anything. Need HR and RBI and AVe. Was offered Fielder,Ichiro and Porcello for Halladay,Kinsler and Span. Only thing that scares me with Kinsler is the missed games every year. Most likely not gonna do it, just wanted any other opinions.

[NikeTxGuy]

I'd say no... Keep Fielder... He'll benefit you more than Kinsler, though Kinsler is viewed as a stud to some.

HELP PLZ?
viewtopic.php?t=384963

[surlytruckdrivr]

no, I'd be getting the Fielder side

Thought of countering with Halladay for Fielder straight up

[NikeTxGuy]

Halladay for Fielder? Yes, do that.

HELP PLZ?
viewtopic.php?t=384963

[divelaw71]

Fielder for Halladay would be fair. That would be the ONLY way I would make the deal.

help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384970

[brotherbird]

What are your P settings? I know a pitcher only goes about 3x in 2 weeks, but not too many innings eaters like Holliday that will get you complete games. I'm leaning with you, surly. BTW, like your moniker. I'm in the same "profession".

[surlytruckdrivr]

I countered back with 2 offers

Halladay/Span for Fielder/Porcello

and Halladay/Kinsler/Span for M Cabrera/Ichiro/Porcello

see what happens

[wallywojo]

I like you second time around offer there. In the first I do not think you are getting enough back. Great 2b are hard to find especially with Uggla and Ramirez struggling. Good luck with that.

help with mine? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=384983

[surlytruckdrivr]

so after we've negotiated for a while, here's the latest offer. He offered me;

Arod, Ichiro, Porcello and Lidge, for Halladay, Kinsler, Span and Figgins

should I accept

[surlytruckdrivr]

bump