Big trade...Rollins/Scherzer for Berkman/Lester?

[Pitch12]

12 team head to head league....5x5 scoring...Currently in first but looking to improve...What do you think of this

I give up: Rollins/Scherzer

I get: Berkman/Lester

I would have Alexei move to SS. Here's my roster. Thoughts are appreciated. Thanks!

C Russell Martin
, LAD C

1B Prince Fielder
, Mil 1B

2B Brian Roberts
, Bal 2B

3B Chris Davis
, Tex 1B, 3B

SS Jimmy Rollins
, Phi SS

IF Alexei Ramirez
, CHW 2B/SS

OF Nate McLouth
, Pit OF

OF Shane Victorino
, Phi OF

OF Hunter Pence
, Hou OF

OF Juan Pierre
, LAD OF

UTIL Coco Crisp
, KC OF

Bench Elijah Dukes
, Was OF  DTD

Bench Mike Jacobs, KC 1B

DL Aramis Ramirez
*, ChC 3B  DL15

Bench
PITCHERS
SLOT PLAYER, TEAM POS
P Adam Wainwright
, StL SP

P Chad Qualls
, Ari RP

P Aaron Harang
, Cin SP

P Justin Verlander
, Det SP PP

P Matt Lindstrom
, Fla RP

P Scott Downs
, Tor RP

P Dave Bush
, Mil SP PP

P Juan Cruz
, KC RP

Bench Max Scherzer
, Ari SP

Bench Mark Buehrle
, CWS SP

Bench Gavin Floyd
, CWS SP

Bench Doug Davis
, Ari SP
DL B.J. Ryan
*, Tor RP  DL15

[Pitch12]

Thoughts?

[philaphan]

I like the deal. Lester is better than Scherzer and Berkman will give you more vlaue than Rollins. I do think Rollins will bounce back but so will Berkman. I would do this deal!

Please help me!
viewtopic.php?t=384911

[divelaw71]

Close one-Rollins gives you speed and runs but his pop is waning. Lester is the key: he is better than Max. Take the Lester side.

help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384970

[brotherbird]

This is very close, like divelaw said. You have good 1B's. I think the key is you being in first place, and Rollins hasn't even helped you yet. If Rollins heats up, his value @ SS would make your offense even more potent; enough to overcome pitching deficiency, if that's what you think you need. Good luck!