My Hamilton/Kershaw for Adam Jones/Justin Uptin?

[DLim98]

I was just wondering what you guys thought about this trade? Hamilton hasn't been looking great and on the other side Jones looks amazing this year. I don't know if I really need to pitching and Kershaw has been inconsistent.

ESPN
10 Team, 5x5 Roto League
HR, Avg, Steals, RBI, Runs
ERA, WHIP, K's, Wins, Saves

C Joe Mauer
1B Adrian Gonzalez
2B Ian Kinsler
SS Troy Tulowitzki
2B/SS Rickie Weeks
3B Aubrey Huff
1B/3B Chris Davis
OF Alfonso Soriano
OF BJ Upton
OF Shane Victorino
OF Josh Hamilton
OF Denard Span
Util Adrian Beltre
Bench Marco Scutaro
DL Aramis Ramirez*
Bench Kendry Morales
Bench Billy Butler

P Dan Haren
P Francisco Liriano
P Yovani Gallarado
P Javier Vazquez
P Ervin Santana*
P Clayton Kershaw
P Matt Garza
P Matt Lindstrom
P Bobby Jenks
DL Chris Carpenter

[Sportsmonkey]

I wouldn't do it. While its obviously not Kershaw's time yet, Hamilton has proven he is a stud and the jury is still out on Jones and Upton. They are both going to be studs, but might be raw yet. Jones in particular is due to come down a bit.

[DLim98]

What would you think of me offering bj upton as a counter instead of hamilton. So BJ Upton/Kershaw for AJones/JUpton

[lilfrier]

No chance he'll accept that.

[Tireur]

I wouldn't trade hamilton. He's gonna be a stud this year, don't throw away your top draft pick for a couple guys that could have been picked off the waiver this year in most 10 team leagues. Kershaw will probably pull it together by the end of the year too. You can get so much more trade value out of these two players, and I also wouldn't try selling them as you'd be selling low on hamilton and kershaw and buying high on upton and jones.

[kingmike74]

Not in a million years man, even prior to last night.

Help me
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384954