Hunter/O Cabrera/Drew Bailey for Webb/Lidge/Renteria? WHIR

[Sportsmonkey]

12 team mixed 5x5 roto non-keeper.

I'm in 4th place, but my OF is deep with Quentin (blah), Soriano, Braun, Torii Hunter and a bunch of later pickups like Fowler/Choo/Snider/Laporta.

I sent out a message looking to move an OF for an SP or closer and got this offer back.

Is it too good to pass up? I could drop Gordon to free up a DL spot for a month. Or I could swap Webb for Volstad.

Thanks!

Team:

SP - Billingsly, Joba, Kershaw, Myers
RP - Mariano, Valverde, Bailey
C - V-Mart
1B - Berkman
2B - J Lopez
SS - O Cab
3B - Lowell
CI - Delgado/Blake
MI - Castillo
OF - Braun, Soriano, Quentin, Hunter, Choo
DH - Laporta/Snider

[litlmess15]

I'd say do it in hopes that Webb's arm returns to normal when he gets back, which could be a while. I like the other parts of the deal for ya too. I'd pull the trigger and pray.

[LetsGoYankees]

You could definitely use Webb, but he's still out for awhile longer and who knows if he will be the same. I'd try maybe going for a different SP, but if you can't do another deal then I'd say do this deal.

[Sportsmonkey]

You could definitely use Webb, but he's still out for awhile longer and who knows if he will be the same. I'd try maybe going for a different SP, but if you can't do another deal then I'd say do this deal.

Would you rather have Volstad for 5 months or Webb for 4 months with a little more risk? The deal doesn't look as good if its Volstad.

I think that if Webb is healthy enough to pitch, he'll be his old dominant self.

[LetsGoYankees]

You could definitely use Webb, but he's still out for awhile longer and who knows if he will be the same. I'd try maybe going for a different SP, but if you can't do another deal then I'd say do this deal.

Would you rather have Volstad for 5 months or Webb for 4 months with a little more risk? The deal doesn't look as good if its Volstad.

I think that if Webb is healthy enough to pitch, he'll be his old dominant self.

I'd rather have Webb, I think Volstad has gotten very lucky so far.

[Sportsmonkey]

I pulled the trigger. Just too much potential to pass up.