Who is the better 3B?

[jonpistone2]

In a standard 5 x 5 league...non keeper...who is going to have the better numbers from today till the end of the year? Please place your vote and explain why.
thank you!!

[smoovethug]

ARod assuming he's healthy. Better player, better lineup, better park.

[lilfrier]

Wright has more speed and is only 25 or so, so he's only going to get better. A-Rod is in a lineup full of guys well past their prime (Jeter, Damon, Godzilla, A-Rod himself, Posada), Nady's going to be probably at 75% at best, and Swisher is playing a bit over his head. Wright has a great OBP guy in Reyes, Murphy's a decent young hitter, and Beltran's about as consistent as anyone in baseball. I think a good deal of the Yankees offense is based on names rather than talent. I also would take Longoria over A-Rod, and probably Wright too.