volquez for holliday? WHIR guaranteed

[Bravos of Steel]

An owner is offering me Corey Hart, Max Scherzer, and Edinson Volquez for my Matt Holliday, Mark Buerhle, and Ervin Santana. I'm havin a real tough time accepting this trade mainly because I really think Holliday will start coming around, Buerhle's really steppin it up, and I'm not completely sold on Max Scherzer. On the other hand, Holliday may turn out to be a bust (based on his ADP) and I'll be getting Volquez. Put your myself in my shoes: Would you accept this trade? I'll post my team, and I will help in return. Leave a link fellas

C Victor Martinez
1B Justin Morneau
2B Aaron Hill, Howie Kendrick
3B Ryan Zimmerman, Mark Reynolds
SS J.J. Hardy
OF Matt Holliday
OF Nelson Cruz
OFJacoby Ellsbury
Util. Denard Span, Niger Morgan
DL Vlad Guerrero

SP Doc Holliday
SP John Danks
SP Mark Buerhle
SP Kevin Slowey
SP Nick Blackburn
SP Randy Wolf
RP Ryan Franklin
RP George Sherrill
RP Latroy Hawkins
RP Brandon Morrow
DL Ervin Santana
DL Dice-K

[JMB05]

An owner is offering me Corey Hart, Max Scherzer, and Edinson Volquez for my Matt Holliday, Mark Buerhle, and Ervin Santana. I'm havin a real tough time accepting this trade mainly because I really think Holliday will start coming around, Buerhle's really steppin it up, and I'm not completely sold on Max Scherzer. On the other hand, Holliday may turn out to be a bust (based on his ADP) and I'll be getting Volquez. Put your myself in my shoes: Would you accept this trade? I'll post my team, and I will help in return. Leave a link fellas

C Victor Martinez
1B Justin Morneau
2B Aaron Hill, Howie Kendrick
3B Ryan Zimmerman, Mark Reynolds
SS J.J. Hardy
OF Matt Holliday
OF Nelson Cruz
OFJacoby Ellsbury
Util. Denard Span, Niger Morgan
DL Vlad Guerrero

SP Doc Holliday
SP John Danks
SP Mark Buerhle
SP Kevin Slowey
SP Nick Blackburn
SP Randy Wolf
RP Ryan Franklin
RP George Sherrill
RP Latroy Hawkins
RP Brandon Morrow
DL Ervin Santana
DL Dice-K

Not ever, would I accept this trade.

Volquez was a later round pitcher(exactly where he should be drafted) because he K's a lot but walks way too many and most think he is due for a regression.

Add the fact that you have Ervin Santana, who has not pitched yet, and is better than Volquez in almost every way and plays for a better team.

Max Scherzer is an unknown at this point but brings K's to the game and that is all I would expect from him this year, so you get Hart for Burlehe.

Lets recap.

E. Santana >>> Volquez
Holliday >>>>> Hart
Buerhle >Scherzer

So you lose every single one.



If you accept this trade quit fantasy baseball and take up knitting.

[screwball1234]

Now way, the owner is obviously selling high on Volquez because he has had a couple solid starts this trade doesn't help you

help
viewtopic.php?t=384698