adam jones or ichiro WHIR

[fierro33]

have a trade on the table and im trying to figure out which guy to give up


ichiro or adam jones


its

ichiro or adam
chris davis
magglio

for

beckett
sizemore



10 team 5x5 H2H


C Mauer
1b Miguel Cabrera
2b Brian Roberts
3b Alex Rodriguez
ss Michael Young
of Manny ramirez
of Carl Crawford
of Nate Mclouth
util Ichiro Suzuki

bench:
Chris Davis
magglio ordonez
adam jones



SP

CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Kevin Slowey
Josh Johnson
Baker


lidge
fuentes
capps
juan cruz

[dagactor]

I'm a huge Red Sox fan and I'm not a believer in Beckett. That said, I am a believer in Sizemore. Keep Adam Jones...Ichiro is great, but you don't need the steals with Crawford and Sizemore, so go with Jones. And take Manny out of your lineup for the next 47 games. :-(

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384648

[fierro33]

anyone else?

[lilfrier]

Is this guy really dumb enough to give you that deal? Trade Ichiro, no question. 23 years old or 33? Pretty obvious answer.

[fierro33]

really?? i thought i might be kinda giving up too much for ovverrated sizemore and aging beckett lol

[RASportsnut]

Trade Ichiro, keep Jones. Jones is really coming into his own, fantastic upside. He may fast become your next Sizemore (I don't mean the slumping one, lol).

[Ravens Black]

Definetly Ichiro. No question! Jones is going to be and alreday is showing way more talent then anyone expected. Jones is a legit keeper in any league.