Dunn Trade Whir

[DABEAR]

I get
· Ryan Dempster
·Magglio Ordonez

I give
·Adam Dunn

i need pitching ant thopughr on this trade

5x5 16 team roto
Scoring BA R RBIS SB HR
ERA W SAVES WHIP K'S
Batters
Ramon Hernandez C
Brian Roberts MI
Troy Tulowitzki MI
Kendry Morales CI
Albert Pujols CI
Milton Bradley OF
Adam Dunn OF
Jermaine Dye OF
Alex Rios OF
Grady Sizemore OF
Pitchers
Scott Baker SP
Fausto Carmona SP
Johnny Cueto SP
Kyle Davies SP
Armando Galarraga SP
Sean Marshall SP
Scott Downs RP
Carlos Zambrano SP

Reserve Batters
Josh Fields CI
Luke Scott OF
Matt Laporta OF
Reserve Pitchers
R. Soriano

[activechamp2006]

I'd have to say you're losing this deal by a pretty wide margin.

[Oatsdad]

I'd have to say you're losing this deal by a pretty wide margin.

And I'd agree. Unless Ordonez and Dempster dig themselves out of their crappy early seasons and/or Dunn goes into the toilet, this isn't a good trade for you.

Who're you dropping to make extra space, BTW?

[bats2584]

I would stand pat, I don't think Maggs is a strong enough buy low player and you can trade Dunn straight up for a pitcher.

Help me fix my pitching...
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384644