TRADE HELP GREINKE unsure of value

[rgkid144]

Alright heres the deal....im giving rollins joba and mcclouth......gettin greinke tulowitzki and bj upton......i could use the pitching my rotation pre deal is peavy joba burnett floyd and ervin santana this week when he comes back...let me know if its doable PLEASE HELP

[philaphan]

I would have to see the rest of your roster but Greinke is much better than Joba and will help your pitching. I think McClouth has more value than Upton and Rollins is still better than Tulo even if he is terrible right now.

I do disgree with you on Rollins...he is not over the hill! Yes he is a joke right now but it is only May and I truely believe he is going to bounce back and a a solid year. He bats in a hiiter friendly park with a grat offensive lineup. I am not just saying this about Rollins because I just completed a trade to get him.

Thanks for the help with mine!

[justink15]

I honestly think you could get anyone for Greinke one on one, at least in my league you could. I like that trade and would do it is what I am saying.

[Oatsdad]

I honestly think you could get anyone for Greinke one on one, at least in my league you could.

Not in my league. I tried to swap Greinke straight up for Halladay and for Braun but was denied. (Also tried for J. Santana and Lincecum, but I was 99% sure those wouldn't get accepted.) Too many people are skeptical of Greinke and don't think he'll keep up his fast start.

I'd take the trade in question, though...