Dunn/Clay Buchholz for Jose Reyes/Hughes/Ethier

[brykater14]

H2H 10 team mixed Keeper League

Offensive Categories:
Runs, HR, RBI, SB, TB, AVG, OBP

Here is my team:
C -- None (these tend to hurt the Avg/Obp stats)
1B - Chris Davis
2B - Dustin Pedroia
SS - Mike Aviles
3B - Evan Longoria
OF - Ryan Braun
OF - Carlos Beltran
OF - Adam Dunn
Util - Rickie Weeks (only on the team since Ramirez is hurt)
Bench - Aramis Ramirez
Bench - Matt LaPorta (picked him up in anticipation of losing Dunn)

I would be giving up Adam Dunn and Clay Buchholz for Joes Reyes, Phil Hughes, and Andre Ethier. Then I would dump Aviles.

I am worried about giving up the homeruns and RBIs that Dunn will get me and that Ethier has better stats when Manny is around. But between Reyes and Ethier, they come close to producing the same amount of HRs that Dunn does. I like Reyes since I barely lose Runs every week and with Reyes, that should help out. Last year, Ethier had better stats than Dunn in Runs, SB, TB, and Avg; their OBP was basically a tie, so the only thing I would be losing is HR and RBIs. However, with Reyes, I would be gaining a lot more Runs and Stolen bases.

Would you do this trade? Thanks in advance

WHIR