Grady Sizemore for Lincecum? WHIR always

[the free basers]

12 team H2H league. 6x6 (r, hr, rbi, sb, avg, obg, w, l, sv, k, era, whip)

my team
c. mccann
1b. morneau
2b. cano
3b. rolen
ss. a. cabrera
of. ichiro
of. granderson
of. mclouth
util. pena
util. matsui
bn. wieters

sp. santana
sp. lincecum
rp. bell
rp. soria (cruz since soria is on dl)
p. danks
p. buerhle
p. e. jackson
p. maine
p. washburn
bn. t. hanson
dl. carpenter

his team:
c. napoli
1b. delgado
2b. jose lopez
3b. chris davis
ss. scutaro
of. sizemore
of. c. lee
of. holliday
util. hart
util. hunter
bn. berkman
bn. cameron
dl. stephen drew

sp. greinke
sp. haren
rp. cordero
rp. sherril
p. carmona
p. c. lee
p. wainwright
p. baily
p. orredondo
bn. price

so my dillema is that his pitching would most likely become better than mine, although his hitting would be pretty weak. would you try to package pena and lincecum for sizemore and haren or something similar, or just do the deal straight up, and go toe to toe with him each week, what do you think?

[lilfrier]

I'd try adding Pena for Haren or MAYBE Cliff Lee, but it's close either way. Pitching can get more points than hitting, but pitchers are a much bigger health risk.

[the free basers]

thanks for the reply. I actually ended up countering the offer with my mclouth, lincecum, and washburn, for his sizemore, berkman (who is on his bench right now) and c. lee. will see what happens, but will probably be able to find a middle ground at some point.

anyone think i should just do the deal straight up?

[lilfrier]

Cliff or Carlos?

[the free basers]

sorry, didn't even think of that. cliff.