Weeks for Upton?

[minimole5848]

Hey I am thinking about a trade what do you think...

Ok my team looks like this
Joe Mauer, C
Carlos Pena, 1B
Chase Utley, 2B
Evan Longoria, 3B
Jimmy Rollins, SS
Adam Dunn, Hideki Matsui, Shane Victorino OF
A-Rod U

Reserve Batters: Yadier Molina and Ricky Weeks

SP (three are reserves but they switch week to week)
Chad Billingsley
Johnny Cueto
Matt Garza
Zack Greinki
Aaron Harang
Joba Chamberlain
Fransisco Lirano
Tommy Hanson

RP
Fransisco Cordero
Brad Lidge

So heres the trade...

I am trading Ricky Weeks away to get BJ Upton and was wonder what everyone's thoughts on the trade were? Also where else you think I may need to strengthen besides OF?

Thank You for your Help,
Mike

[WyldStallyn]

are you proposing that? if so thats insulting. if that was offered you should already have clicked 'accept.' i would look to grab another closer, but otherwise the team looks pretty good.

[minimole5848]

are you proposing that? if so thats insulting. if that was offered you should already have clicked 'accept.' i would look to grab another closer, but otherwise the team looks pretty good.

Well I proposed this thinking that with some studs on my team he would counter but he just accepted flat out...I was thrilled granted upton is ice cold and weeks is on fire but still I believe I got the better end of this one. Also he was desperate for 2B help and if weeks keeps producing like he is right now it will be good for both sides.

Yeah I think I need a closer too but those trades are always hard for me because I am not a fan of relief pitchers...I never know what to give up to get one ya know? what do you suggest? who should I go for and who should I try to give up for him?

Thanks for the help...