Trade Greinke for Halladay? WHIR!

[angels7777]

instead of essentially going for a lateral move here, try to upgrade SP and upgrade one other spot too

viewtopic.php?t=384216

[Zain1two3]

Definetly hit that trade button. Halladay has the track record, he has got all the stuff you could want. Innings eater, low era, great K/BB ratio, low WHIP and wins. He plays for the Jays and Greinke for the Royals so there's obviously a better chance of Halladay picking up a win with the Jays' hot offence than for the Royals.

[Mathew11.]

Greinke will cool down and wont even be a top 3 pitcher for the CY when its all set and done. Halliday is the BEST pitcher in baseball. game 7 of the World series i would take no1 else then Halliday cuz hes the BEST!!

[ROC AllStars]

Greinke is better. Everyone knew Zack had elite talent, the only thing holding him back was the anxiety disorder. Now that house is in order, and he is the best AL pitcher now. I'm still concerned about strikeout upside with Halladay.

Seven starts is not nearly enough of a sample size to claim that Grienke is better than Halladay, no matter how good those starts are.