Do I make this deal?

[RDD15]

16-team league with 40-man (8 minors) rosters. 9 Major and 8 Minor keepers at no cost. H2H points.

I give: Rolen, Kazmir, Saltalamacchia and Jeff Clement (Minors Catcher-Seattle)

I get: Cano, Liriano, Laird, and either Michael Stanton (Minors OF-Florida) or Aaron Poreda (Minors SP-Whte Sox)

I have Ryan Zimmerman at 3B currently, Rolen is a bench guy. Kaz Matsui is my 2B, Iannetta my C.

My view on Kazmir vs Liriano is that Kazmir has lost a few MPH on his fastball and could be Verlander '08. Liriano has shown decent stuff and is getting horribly unlucky to give up all the runs that he is.

At this point, my major league keepers for next year would be
Pujols
A Gonzalez
Zimmerman
Upton
Upton
Granderson
Kemp
Billingsley
Kershaw

So none of the major league guys in the trade are looking like keepers.

[warbird1]

I would do it for an upgrade at 2B in Cano...Liriano and Kazmir are a wash at this point and Laird will have a good season in Detroit.

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=384160