Downs or ziegler

[D.Piston]

who would you keep?

[galacticat]

Downs.

[chargersfan36]

Downs.

viewtopic.php?t=384031

[Bozo]

Downs for sure, the way Ryan has been performing (combination of injury and ineffectiveness) I think Downs will figure into the Jays closing situation for the remainder of the year. Ziegler could end up sharing closing duties with a couple of different possibilities (Bailey, Casilla, Wuertz, Springer) in a very strong A's bullpen.

[kidsilk]

Downs too

please help

viewtopic.php?t=384109

[Seanyfever]

Downs easily.


Help out a Cafe brother???
viewtopic.php?t=384095

[Surfs up]

Ryan is coming off the DL soon. Downs might keep the job in short term but if he bombs Ryan will be there ready to reclaim the job. Zeigler has been sick and Baily has gottena couple of chances for saves . Zeigler I think is the better choice but its almost a toss up. Given Ryan was the closer for a while and has the most expirence I think Downs ould lose out quicker then Zeigler.