Upton/Qualls for Holliday/Hawkins WHIR

[ultrazero]

I've been offered an enticing trade. Wondering what the Cafe thinks. Has offered his BJ Upton and Chad Qualls for my Matt Holliday and Latroy Hawkins. Trying to buy low on Holliday while hoping I'll take a chance on Upton. Upton has a big upside. The established closer for a fill in is enticing. I'm thinking about stayin put. What do you think. WHIR.


C Joe Mauer
1B MCab
2B B Phillips
3B Longoria
SS JJ Hardy
CI M Reynolds
MI Y Escobar
OF Ethier/Holliday/Ordonez/Hawpe
Util Scutaro
BN Teahen/Aviles/Conor Jackson
DL Glaus/Guillen

SP Greinke/Harang/Beckett/Garza/Dempster/Volquez/Buehrle
RP Papelbon/K-Rod/Hawkins/Ray

[Hit Factory]

I would make this trade in a second! Upton has a much higher upside than Holliday, who imo, will be pretty mediocre in Oakland. Qualls is better, and much more valuable than Hawkins since Valverde will come back and take over the closer role. Make this deal!

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=383792