Your Dream Prospect Team

[the ROC]

Who would be in your starting lineup for a 'dream team' of prospects/rookies?

C -
1B -
2B -
SS -
3B -
LF -
CF -
RF -
DH -

Ace -
SP2 -
SP3 -
SP4 -
SP5 -

Setup -
Closer -

[thomasps3]

[quote="the ROC"]Who would be in your starting lineup for a 'dream team' of prospects/rookies?

C -Matt Wieters
1B - Justin Smoak
2B - Gordon Beckham (Gotta put him here)
SS - Tim Beckham
3B - Pedro Alvarez
LF - Travis Snider
CF - Colby Rasmus
RF - Jason Heyward
DH - Mike Moustakas

Ace - David Price
SP2 - Madison Bumgarner
SP3 - Stephen Strasburg
SP4 - Tommy Hanson
SP5 - Brett Anderson

Setup - Daniel Bard
Closer - Neftali Feliz


Love the 3 LHP in the rotation..Bard is untouchable in high leverage innings, and it is just a matter of time before Feliz is converted to closer....

[Bobbleheadrusty]

C -Matt Wieters
1B - Justin Smoak
2B - Jemile Weeks (Trying not to cheat, best of a bad position imho)
SS - Tim Beckham
3B - Pedro Alvarez
LF - Travis Snider
CF - Dexter Fowler
RF - Jason Heyward
DH - Mike Moustakas

Ace - David Price
SP2 - Madison Bumgarner
SP3 - Jarrod Parker
SP4 - Tommy Hanson
SP5 - Rick Porcello (assuming his early debut doesnt wreck him)

Setup - David Hernandez
Closer - Neftali Feliz

[Steve-o]

Fun Post. Pretty sure I am taking only guys without any MLB experience.

C - Matt Wieters
1B - Lars Anderson
2B - Brett Lawrie
SS - Tim Beckham
3B - Pedro Alvarez
LF - Jason Heyward
CF - Andrew McCutchen
RF - Michael Stanton
DH - Justin Smoak (the glove would play at 1b as well)

Ace - Madison Bumgarner
SP2 - Chris Tillman
SP3 - Brian Matusz
SP4 - Jhoulys Chacin
SP5 - Jarrod Parker

Setup - Jeremy Jeffress
Closer - Neftali Feliz

[kab21]

Somehow I've been able to assemble this squad in my 24 team dynasty. Obviously it can't quite compete against the best of the best but it's pretty nice. And thus it's my dream team. My MLB pitching is a little thin (no #5 starter) but the pipeline is setup at most positions.

C - Jesus Montero
1B - Chris Marrero
2B - Jemile Weeks
SS - Adrian Cardenas
3B -
LF - Zach Collier
CF - Aaron Hicks
RF - Ryan Westmoreland
DH - Tyler Flowers, Max Ramirez, Adam Moore

Ace - Jordan Zimmerman
SP2 - Jarrod Parker
SP3 - Kyle Drabek
SP4 - Martin Perez
SP5 - (Balester, Odorizzi, or Danny Gutierrez)

Setup - James McDonald
Closer - Bobby Parnell

[Havok1517]

I'm in....

C - M. Weiters
1B - J. Smoak
2B - G. Beckman
SS - T. Beckham (I'd pick USC's Green here if I could)
3B - P. Alvarez
LF - J. Heyward
CF - A. McCutchen
RF - M. Stanton
DH - L. Anderson

Ace - M. Bumgarner
SP2 - T. Hansen
SP3 - C. Carrasco
SP4 - J. Parker
SP5 - E. Martin
(I'd pick SDS's Strasburg here if I could)

Setup - J. Chacin
Closer - H. Rodriguez

PS: I decided to choose nobody with MLB time.

[AEMRICH]

i'll go with my roster in an 18 team dynasty league with 25 my minor league rosters
c- jesus montero
1B- Justin Smoak
2B- i don't have one but will go with Gordon Beckham
3B- Mike Moustakas
SS- Alcedes Escobar
OF-Jason Heyward
OF-Andrew McCutcheon
OF-Ben Revere
DH- Yonder Alonso

SP-CaHill
SP-Porcello
SP-Holland
SP-Feliz
SP- Tillman

i like the combo of speed, power, hitting ability and fielding ability, good mix in the rotation of guys with great stuff and guys who get GO's

[Curtis Pride]

Minor leaguers only (which also excludes Strasburg)

C: Weiters
1B: Smoak
2b: Emaus
SS: T. Beckham
3B: Alvarez
LF: Heyward
CF: McCutchen
RF: Stanton
DH: Lars

Leaving off Posey, Montero, Gamel, and Jennings was the toughest.

SP: Price, Bumgarner, Feliz, Tillman, Hanson
Setup: Jeffress
Closer: Bard

[JohnTucker0814]

i'll try:

C - Carlos Santana (cle)
1B - Kyle Blanks (sd)
2B - Gordan Beckham (chw)
3B - Pedro Alvarez (pit)
SS - Tim Beckham (tb)
OF - Andrew McCutheon (pit)
OF - Mike Stanton (fla)
OF - Josh Reddick (bos)
DH - Matt Gamel (mil)

SP - Madison Bumgarner (sf)
SP - Tommy Hanson (atl)
SP - Ethan Martin (la)
SP - Jarrod Parker (ari)
SP - Aaron Poreda (chw)

A few of those guys are favorites of mine because they are on my minor league roster... but how fun would it be to have these guys as your minor league roster?

[King Tim]

C Weiters
1B Smoak
2B Lawrie
SS G. Beckham
3B Gamel
LF Heyward
CF Hicks
RF D. Brown
DH Montero/Stanton

P Price
P Hanson
P Matusz
P Parker
P Bumgarner/Rondon