Did I "Win" this trade?

[lane_anasazi2]

All else being equal, which side of this trade do you want in a 12 team, H2H, 7x7 league? (the other categories are BB and OPS for hitters and L and K/9 for pitchers)

Nick Markakis, Justin Upton, and Jered Weaver

Or:

David Wright, Joey Votto

[machine3]

Wright/Votto

[h2wm]

I'd take the David Wright and Joey Votto side for sure, as that team is getting two top 30 hitters. Markakis is a great player. But Weaver (a top 50 pitcher) and Upton isn't enough for the return in a 12-team league.

[MadDog36]

David Wright, Joey Votto