Rookie needs help!

[Adrenalized]

Hi, I am a relative rookie to fantasy baseball. I play in a 10 team total bases league. 1 point for single, 2 for double etc. etc. etc.
No defense or pitching, so it is a basic beginner league. My starting line-up consists of Pujols, Alexei Ramirez, Chipper Jones, Tulowitzki, Benji Molina and Manny, Carlos Quentin and Lind/Pence in the outfield.
Backups are Garrett Atkins 1b and 3b, Placido Polanco at 2b, Luke Scott and Rick Ankiel in the OF with Shoppach at C.
I was offered a trade recently. Alex Rodriguez and Tori Hunter for Hunter Pence and Manny Ramirez.
I would like to re-offer A-rod and Hunter for Atkins and Manny. Am I a fool? Any ideas or comments? Thanks!

[jmcampbe11]

You should be able to get a better 2nd player then Atkins for who you're giving up. A-Rod's pretty much back to full value at this point, which means he's an early 1st round pick.

[Adrenalized]

Thanks for the reply.
I am giving up Atkins and Manny for A-rod and Tori Hunter.
You think I need to got more value for my players?

[jmcampbe11]

Thanks for the reply.
I am giving up Atkins and Manny for A-rod and Tori Hunter.
You think I need to got more value for my players?

My mistake. I like the trade for you then. Do it. A-Rod > Manny AND Hunter > Atkins.

[Adrenalized]

Thanks for the reply. Sometimes it just helps to have that second opinion.
Great site btw!
Now my wife is really going to hate me, I will be here all the time now too.