Veto trade or allow???? Help please

[chennemann]

Zorph's Warriors (Players to Trade)

Batters Opp H/AB AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB
A. Ramírez (ChC - 3B) 165/607 607 75 165 32 2 27 106 2 2 42
E. Hinske (Tor - 3B) 109/449 449 74 109 45 3 12 63 12 2 59

Skys the Limit (NYY) (Players to Trade)
Pitchers Opp IP W L SV OUT ER BB K
M. Rivera (NYY - RP) 70.2 5 2 40 212 13 10 63
Drop
Batters Opp H/AB AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB
S. Spiezio (Sea - 1B,3B) 138/521 521 69 138 36 7 16 83 6 3 46

This is a points league and the categories are: AB (.3), R (2), H (1), 2B (3), 3B (4), HR (8), RBI (2), SB (4), CS (-1), BB (1), IP (1), W (30), L (-5), SV (15), OUT (1), ER (-1), BB (-1), K (3)

Skys the Limit would start Ramirez at 3b and Hinske at Corner IF. He also has enough pitchers that he is going to go over the limit of 1400. Rivera though is the best pitcher he has per inning pitched.

Let me know your thoughts.

[Payne Dailey]

seems fair enough to me.

[BoSox4life]

Yup.

[Guest]

Rivera was taken in the second round. For some reason Ramariz lasted to the 11th and Hinske the 18th.

I have no idea why the guy wiht Rivera didn't draft a better 3b.

[canibus]

Rivera was taken in the second round. For some reason Ramariz lasted to the 11th and Hinske the 18th.

I have no idea why the guy wiht Rivera didn't draft a better 3b.

Seeing how he is about to get two 3B's for Rivera, it appears he knows what he's doing

Kind of a wierd trade, I agree, but not really vetoable. Ramirez and Hinske are both top 10 3B's and Rivera is the man, but, one has to wonder how often the Yanks are going to be looking to bring him in to finish a game. Right?

[CBMGreatOne]

I hate the fact that it's an 11 and 18 for a 2, but Aramis Ramirez should never have lasted that long in the draft, especially in a points league with that scoring, and Rivera should never have gone that early.

I see Rivera as more of a 5th round pick and Ramirez as more of an 8th or ninth round pick, so I wouldn't veto.

[Chiefscards]

Looks pretty fair in comparison to some trades I've seen allowed in a couple of my leagues. Dont see any reason for a veto.

[B.O.S. Owner]

Well, I understand your concern...but I wouldn't veto. Aramis may actually even it out, I expect a strong season from him. Going on history though, Mariano is clearly the man.

[Madison]

No veto from me. Must have been an odd draft, but this trade is fair enough to go through.

[Ajax]

The trade looks fine to me.

Just speculating...but the guy picking up Hinske and Ramirez may be planning on trading one of them to someone else that's weak at 3B that has something he wants.