rollins/dice for furcal/gallardo?

[Wile E Coyote]

i have been offered rollins, dice-K and jordan zimmerman for MY furcal and gallardo

neither furcal nor rollins have been good this year but both seem to slowly be getting better?

would you make this deal?
thanks!

[travisjz]

Dice-K sounds ready to return, so I think you make out better at both P and SS in this trade. Give it a go.

[coma]

I wouldn't do this. Gallardo is a stud, and I don't believe in Rollins.

[Padres Fan]

I like getting Rollins for Furcal, but giving up Gallard would hurt, I know zimmerman is a intriguing prospect, but he does play for Washington.

Help With Mine?
viewtopic.php?t=383204

[bobellis75]

I love Gallardo...would be hard to part with him....but I like Rollins better than Furcal too. Tough decision.

[Hit Factory]

I would do it, Rollins is a first round pick and Dice-K will come back healthy and should be pretty effective. Even if Rollins doesn't have his best season he will be any worse than Furcal. Plus Zimmerman is going to be awesome and even if he plays on a crappy team he should help your peripherals.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=383270

[Yankeesin05]

100% do this NOW

[davdav]

Go for it!

[Guzman24]

I would do it too.

Rollins will come around. DiceK and Zimm although not on the same level as Gallardo should be solid for you this year.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=383446

[Horned Frog]

I think it looks good but who do you drop. Dice-K benefitted from crazy defense and luck with runners on last year so it could catch him a little but that offense can support him although the league does tend to catch onto/up to some of the imported pitchers.
Gallardo may be in trouble for defense and has had to provide his on run support once already but his K's are sick like the swine flu.
Rollins has better career numbers than Furcal and he HAS TO GET BETTER right???
So who do you drop for Zimmerman.
I like the deal if you trust that Rollins will definitely rebound far better than raffy. I'm still hesitant but good luck. Sorry this is more analysis than decision?