Roberts, Peavy deal - WHIR

[dave knight]

I give: Chris Davis, Brian Roberts
I get: Jake Peavy, Kelly Johnson, Jason Werth (If this is not good enough, must I ask for Adam Jones or Ludwick for Werth? But tell me if it is good enough as is.)

Good deal or no? I do need some consistent ERA and WHIP help. 1 year, deep 11 team roto.
Categories:
R, H, HR, RBI, SB, BB, TB, AVG, SLG
IP, W, CG, SHO, SV, K, HLD, ERA, WHIP

My team:

C - Inge, Iannetta
1B - Berkman, Votto
2B - Roberts, Weeks
3B - Wright, Chipper
SS - Andrus, Luis Rodriguez
LF - Manny
CF - McLouth
RF - Dukes
OF - Cust, Snider, Headley
Util - Nyjer Morgan
DL - S. Drew

SP - Greinke, Harden, Randy Johnson, Nolasco, Lowe, Sanchez, Jimenez
RP - Cordero, Bell, Arredondo, R. Soriano, Affeldt

[eggplantwizard]

thanks for the help on mine. i wouldn't do it. you wouldnt have a reliable guy at 2b as johnson is losing playing time, but it is still a close offer.

[lilfrier]

I didn't get past the offer to the rest of the post. The yes was THAT obvious to me. Thanks for help with mine.

[Tis]

Peavy is a top 5 pitcher easy when healthy, sounds good to me.

[gws226]

I'm nervous of Peavy home/road splits and the ongoing threat of being moved outside of Petco. Regardless of whether or not he gets traded, I don't think he finishes the season as top 5 pitcher.

I'm also nervous about Johnson's prospects (I traded him for Wang, then he went to waivers in a 10 teamer)

My opinion changes dramatically if Ludwick or Jones is added to the deal though

viewtopic.php?t=383182