Garza for Jenks ? (WHIR)

[jweb2244]

Who wins just based on value?

[SDDECK]

You are comparing apples to oranges as they fulfill two different needs but if you are making me choose I'd say Jenks as SVs are harder to come by on the WW then a SP.

[coma]

I like Jenks as well. Garza is too up and down for my liking.

[litlmess15]

if were talking standard 5x5 leauges here, Garza has more value. Jenks will get saves, but doesnt contribute much in other areas( not enough innings to make an impact) a solid , streaky pitcher like Garza can do some good work for a squad if used properly.



heres mine!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=382998

[jweb2244]

Standard 5 x 5 league. Non-keeper. Thanks.

[candyman]

This is tough to gauge based strictly on value...

I'd lean slightly towards Jenks just becuse I view him as a very solid closer... Certainly top 10 or 12 in the league...

Garza is still a bit of a mystery... Will this be the year he puts it all together and finally breaks out? Or will it just be another up and down roller coaster ride?

I'd say I'll go with the proven commodity. Breakout pitchers (Not talking Greinke here, more like last year's Cueto, Volquez, Baker... etc) can always be found by doing your due diligence and stying on top of the young pitchers. Solid, proven commodity closers are tougher to come by, but of course you can always grab some cheap saves off of the WW.

So I guess I'm saying, that in a vacuum I like Jenks, but just slightly...


Help me out,

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=383045