NEED HELP! IS THIS A FAIR TRADE?

[metroclone]

Hey guys,

I have a trade that needs feedback. I am in an AL ONLY 6 team points league with one of the guys in the NFBC leagues. There was a trade just made Kevin Slowey & Brad Zeigler for CC SABATHIA AND JOSE LOPEZ and i filed a complaint to the commissioner and of course since he was getting CC And lopez he thinks it is fair.

Rule on trades is commissioner needs to approve. The guy making the trade is the commissioner.

Commissioners response is that the guy trading CC needs a closer. Thing is the commissioner has Papelbon, Soria and Ziegler. We start 2 RP's & 5 SP's In other words Ziegler is his bench RP.

Am i in the wrong here to say that this is not a fair trade? Or is this a valid trade? Please post your feedback so we can use this to resolve the debate.

[mmassmedia]

Seems bad, but I wouldn't object unless you think is str8 up collusion.

If it is collusion object, otherwise you can protect people from there own stupidity.



help me help you
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=382992

[metroclone]

Thank You for your feedback...please can we have some more input?

[SDDECK]

You can't object because you are jealous. The other team obviously was in desperate need of a closer and was frustrated with the horrible play of CC. Unless there was collusion kick yourself for not being able to milk CC away from him as well as the commish did.

[metroclone]

Its definetly seems collusion to me. A last place team already trailing by 200 pts to the 2nd place guy for 2 bench players. Let me tell you this guy isnt even trading his best players. Slowey and Ziegler are his bench guys....