Hideki Matsui or Matt LaPorta?

[Howie]

I have an empty roster spot. Who would you rather pick up, the young gun or the grizzled vet?

10 team h2h, 6x6 (standard cats plus ops and hr allowed)

c - v. martinez
1b - m. cabrera
2b - cano
3b - a. ramirez
ss - jeter
of - beltran
of - holliday
of - abreu
util - konerko
util - dukes
bench - thome
bench - c. jackson

sp - halladay
sp - kazmir
sp - kershaw
rp - lidge
rp - fuentes
rp - m. gonzalez
p - street
p - lilly
p- harang
bench - meche
dl - lackey
dl - ryan

[silverZ]

LaPorta for the upside. OF like Matsui must be a dime a dozen in a 10 team league.

[Crazed98]

I agree in a 10 team league there is no reason to take Matsui go with LaPorta's possible high upside.

[TheGuru]

take laporta. matsui is done!

help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=382983