Deal Sizmore for Holliday/Loney/King Felix? 100% WHIR!!

[litlmess15]

Should I pull the trigger? I give Sizemore, Jordan Zimmermann, Rand Winn and Ryan Franklin, I get Matt Holliday, James Loney, Pablo Sandoval, Felix Hernandez. 14 team highly competitive h2h.

batter categories: BA, R, RBI, HR, SB, K
pitchers: ERA, WHIP, SV, K, W, L

Heres my squad:

c- none
1b- A.Pujols
2b- K.Matsui
3B- Mike Lowell
ss- Troy Tulowitzki
of- Jonny Damon
of- Grady Sizemore
of- Shin Soo choo
util- Pince Feiler
util- Dexter Fowler
b- Randy Winn
DL- Ryan Doumit

SP- Jake Peavy
SP- Fransisco Liriano
SP- Joba Chamberlain
RP- Brian Fuentes
RP- Heath Bell
p-Kerry wood
p- Roy Oswalt
b- Aaron Harang
b- Ryan Franklin
b- Glen Perkins
b- Jordan Zimmermann


leave a link! 100% responses!

[bcbhockey68]

Man I don't like that trade your giving up a stud and not geting that much in return.


Please Help:

viewtopic.php?t=382598

[coma]

You are definitely losing in this trade. Don't do it.

[cnasty]

I would not do this deal..as you can tell i hate holliday and i think sizemore is by far best player in the deal...your pitching is fine stick with it...keep sizemore

[wtu]

As long as Holliday stays in Oakland he's at the most 3rd/4th rd production so even though Felix is a stud fantasy pitcher id stay put.
Also you actually could use some more depth in your OF if anything, for a 14 team league you have good pitching

thanks for mine

[slagbot]

no, definitely not. you've got the top outfielder with multiple tools -- HR, avg, and steals. that kind of thing is much harder to find than good pitching, and your pitching core is solid -- peavy will come around and there's always cuetos and volquezes as long as you keep up with things and keep an eye on the cafe. this trade basically comes down to sizemore for felix (while you do need a catcher and OF, holliday is unproven outside of CO and you can find an acceptable catcher elsewhere); i'd even be hesitant if he was offering halladay/johan/lince. grady's just so valuable.

help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=382744

[philaphan]

Don't do it. Sizemore is worth more than this offer. Holliday is struggling and while I think his numbers will come up, overall it will be a down year for him. Felix is nice but overall I think you loose on this deal.

Thanks for the help with mine!