CC + Maglio for Felix + Soriano

[uncommonb]

Thoughts? I think its too steep for me...what about Liriano insteaed of Felix. The above offer is on the table


C John Baker(Fla - C)
1B Miguel Cabrera(Det - 1B,3B)
2B Brandon Phillips(Cin - 2B)
3B Ryan Zimmerman(Was - 3B)
SS Derek Jeter(NYY - SS)
IF Aubrey Huff(Bal - 1B,3B)
LF Alfonso Soriano(ChC - LF)
CF Vernon Wells(Tor - CF)
RF Hunter Pence(Hou - RF)
OF Andre Ethier(LAD - LF,RF)
Util Mike Lowell(Bos - 3B)
BN Nate McLouth(Pit - CF)
BN Brian McCann(Atl - C) DL
BN Jeremy Hermida(Fla - LF,RF)
BN Nick Swisher(NYY - 1B,LF,CF,RF)
DL Cristian Guzmán(Was - SS) DL

SP James Shields(TB - SP)
SP Brett Myers(Phi - SP)
SP Félix Hernández(Sea - SP)
SP Francisco Liriano(Min - SP)
RP Jonathan Papelbon(Bos - RP)
RP Carlos Mármol(ChC - RP)
RP Ross Ohlendorf(Pit - SP,RP)
P Chris Young(SD - SP)
P Aaron Harang(Cin - SP)
P Tim Wakefield(Bos - SP)
P Scott Baker(Min - SP)
BN Jordan Zimmermann(Was - SP)
BN David Price(TB - SP) NA
DL Ricky Romero(Tor - SP) DL

[yanks2327]

I think I'd hold tight - I like CC and he's sure to start heating up, and has more run support than Felix, but I think the gap between Soriano and Magglio is far greater than that between CC and Felix - same probably holds true for Liriano.

As a Magglio owner, I'm a bit concerned with him and would accept this trade if I were the other owner.