Reynolds or Atkins?

[go9ers]

Reynolds is on the ww...which 3B would you rather have? If it is Reynolds, who should I drop out of the following:

Jim Thome, Atkins, or Chris B. Young (h2h points league with no penalty for strikeouts/avg)

My team at respective positions:

3B: Atkins
OF: Bay
OF: Sizemore
OF: Dunn
UT: Votto
RP: Morrow
RP: Fuentes

Other options on bench: BJ Ryan, Valverde (injuries)

[zepfan]

I would stick with Atkins for now. Reynolds potential downside for his average scares me.

[MadDog36]

Stick with Atkins. If you want another 3b cut Ryan.

[Singles]

I would stick with Atkins also but since your league doesn't countAvg and K's then Reynolds is a good pick up also. Like MadDog said maybe cut Ryan.